Sports betting has grown in popularity across the United States over the last ten years, with horse racing remaining one of the most popular options among gamblers.
Making horse race betting online selections is most common around the times of the biggest events in the calendar, with millions of mainstream viewers typically tuning in to watch the Breeders’ Cup, Kentucky Derby, and Belmont Stakes. The Triple Crown remains the most popular with a mainstream audience, with the first Saturday in May typically being the most-watched horse racing event in the U.S.
These events are as popular with experienced bettors as with those who only make a handful of wagers per year. However, betting on horse racing is unlike wagering on any other sport, as the industry is regulated differently from other options in the U.S.
So, how does horse racing betting differ from other sporting options such as American Football and basketball?
Pari Mutuel Betting
One of the biggest differences in betting on horse racing is the odds bettors make their selections on. Fixed-odds betting is common across Europe and the rest of the world when betting on the sport, but in North America, Pari-Mutuel is most prominent.
Here, odds are determined by how many other bettors select the same horse. In this type of betting, the prize pool for each race is determined by the size of the pool, with the track taking its cut.
This can work in bettors’ favor, as odds for outsiders can be much higher than on fixed-odds sites. However, popular favorites will traditionally be even shorter in price in pari-mutuel wagering.
Interstate Horseracing Act
Horse racing has been ahead of the curve in sports betting in the United States, as the Interstate Horseracing Act was passed into law in 1978, before amendments were made in 2000.
The law prohibits accepting an interstate off-track wager on a horse race unless consent is granted by the host racing association, the host racing commission, and the off-track commission.
One of the biggest successes of the law is the fact that it protects the wagering rights, with racetracks and industry stakeholders having a legal framework to control and monetize the simulcast of its racing and the off-track betting of the sport across state lines.
This law shows how differently horse racing is policed compared to other sports, as it allowed bets to be placed on the sport long before general sports betting was legalized across the rest of the United States.
UIGEA Carve-Out
Another example of how horse racing is treated differently from other sports was displayed in 2006, when the Unlawful Internet Gambling Enforcement Act was brought in to crack down on online bookmaking.
While this had a direct impact on other sports and the wagering options available, it was determined that horse racing would be carved out of the law in order to protect the sport.
The carve-out ensured that horse racing could continue to operate nationwide in the years that followed, across a wide range of sports where betting was allowed. During this period, betting on horse racing was still allowed, decades before general online sports betting was made legal.
PASPA and Murphy v. NCAA
One of the biggest changes to sports betting came in 2018 with PASPA and Murphy v. NCAA. This saw the decision to overturn the 1992 Professional and Amateur Sports Protection Act.
The case centered around the dispute between New Jersey, which had passed state laws to allow wagering on sports in its casinos and racetracks. Major sports leagues would argue that this decision violated the PASPA law, while the state argued that the law was unconstitutional.
The Supreme Court struck down the law, enacted in the 90s, which opened the door to legalized sports betting on all sports and allowed states to create and modify their own regulations in response to demand.
Horse Racing Oversight Bodies
Unlike other sports betting options, horse racing is typically governed and regulated by different government agencies. For example, one state may have a Gaming Control Board govern the sport, while another may have a Lottery Commission oversee it.
In racing, state commissions will typically enforce local racing meetings, which includes giving licenses to jockeys and trainers, while also overseeing wagering. However, there is also a federal/uniform layer that is in place following the Horse Racing Integrity and Safety Act. This layer will monitor medical records, anti-doping testing and ensure that the sport is as safe as possible within the state, which includes assessing any potential integrity and welfare issues.
Major regional bodies include the Kentucky Horse Racing Commission and the New York State Gaming Commission, with the latter managing licensing and rule enforcement at all NYRA tracks, including nation-leading venues such as Belmont Park and Saratoga.
